Monday 11 February 2013

The controversy of poisoning rhino horns

African rhino poaching crisis. WWF Global, Gland, C.H. Available from:
http://wwf.panda.org/what_we_do/endangered_species/rhinoceros/african_rhinos/poaching_crisis_african_rhinos/
Emslie, R. 2012. Ceratotherium simum. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species, Cambridge, U.K. Available from:
http://www.iucnredlist.org/details/4185/0
Dean, C. 2010. Poisoning rhino horns. Save the Rhino International, London, U.K. Available from: http://www.savetherhino.org/latest_news/news/326_poisoning_rhino_horns
Platt, J.R. 2012. Spiked. Conservation Magazine, Washington, D.C. Available from:
http://www.conservationmagazine.org/2012/09/spiked/
Rhishja C.L. 2010. Poisoning rhino horn to thwart poaching syndicates in South Africa. Rhino Conservation, Petaluma, C.A. Available from:
http://www.rhinoconservation.org/2010/07/30/poisoning-rhino-horn-to-thwart-poaching-syndicates-in-south-africa/
White rhinos in Southern Africa are listed by the IUCN as near threatened (Emslie 2012). This is due to rhinos being poached for the value of their horn. The value of a rhino's horn is twice that of gold (Platt 2012). This is because rhino horns are used in Asian medicine and are thought to cure fevers, boils, anxiety and have also been thought to cure cancer (Dean 2010). The horn is made out of keratin, the same type of protein found in human nails and hair (Dean 2010). The keratin found in rhino's horns has been tested in several scientific studies and none of them have found it to have any curing effects (Rhishja 2010). The horns are smuggled into Asian markets and sold after the horn has been ground into a fine powder and manufactured into tablets (WWF Global).

Ed Hern is the owner of the Rhino and Lion Nature Reserve near Johannesburg, South Africa (Platt 2012). In previous years Ed Hern has taken in orphaned baby rhinos due to their mothers being killed by poachers (Rhishja 2010). Ed Hern has tried almost everything to prevent poaching on his reserve, he even hired armed guards to protect the rhinos (Platt 2012). In 2010 Ed Hern and his staff proposed putting an anti-tick parasiticide in the horns of the rhinos on his reserve; this will not harm the rhinos because there is no blood flow in their horns (Platt 2012). The anti-tick parasiticide is not lethal to humans, but it causes nausea, convulsions and nervous disorders (Platt 2012). He also proposed adding an indelible dye into the horns that is detected with airport scanners, and putting GPS microchips in the horns of the rhinos to track them (Platt 2012).

South Africa contains more than 80% of the rhino population (WWF Global). What is disturbing is that in 2009 a hundred and twenty-two rhinos were poached, in 2010 three-hundred and thirty-three rhinos were poached, and in 2012 the numbers had reached to three-hundred and eighty-eight rhinos thus far (WWF Global).

The large controversy over the poisoning of rhino horns is that the actual poacher is not receiving the poison, it is the customer that purchases the horns or the tablets in the Asian markets. Even if the poacher were to be the one poisoned; would it still make it okay? It is concerning that Ed Hern has guards protecting his reserve and he is still having poachers killing the rhinos he is trying to protect. Do drastic measures need to be taken when protecting the poaching of rhinos?

Word Count: 400

16 comments:

  1. Poaching is such a huge problem.. we are so greedy! I don't know how I personally feel about poisoning rhino horns. I'm sure it can't be good for the rhinos in the long run. Also, I wonder if the components of the rhino horns can be synthesized in a lab since they are used so widely in Asian medicine.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The rhino horn is made completely out of keratin, meaning there is no blood flow through the horn. This is why Ed Hern wanted to inject the tick-poison because it will not harm the rhino at all. There is no scientific evidence that the keratin in rhino horns has any curing effects.

      Delete
    2. good to know!

      Delete
  2. I think it's a brilliant idea. The only way to stop poaching is to lower the demand. If consumers become aware of the risk of poisoning by taking these pills, a lot of them will be less inclined to buy them. A lower demand results in a lower price and less incentive to poach the rhinos.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post Sally! Really thought provoking. Personally I'd say good luck to Mr. Hern! What great ideas to track and expose poachers. Brilliant. As for the poison, if it's only causing some minor discomfort then I'm all for it. As far as nervous disorders go...are these serious? But I agree with Trina, consumers should be targeted in some way to lower the demand. They are also wasting their money on keratin...something with no proven health benefits.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Some people and their crazy beliefs...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Huh... an interesting quandary. Would then the buyer stop purchasing rhino horns, or would it just increase the demand?

    Or, if it stopped people from hunting upon the reserve, it may increase the pressure upon wild rhinos.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think it's a pretty good idea. Or they could put some other substance on the horn that may attract drug sniffing dogs or go off in the metal detectors. That may be one way to stop the trafficking of the horns

    ReplyDelete
  7. what a nasty situation

    ReplyDelete
  8. It's great to be able to detect the horns that are being exported, but the problem is that the horns are being harvested in the first place. I think there needs to be something in place that works with preventing horn harvest as opposed to horn export - because at that point, it's already too late for the rhino.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with Alyssa, once the horns are harvested by poachers, the damage is done. But I also think that by poisoning the horns and making it very risky for people to own/use products related to rhino horns could be a potential first step in getting consumers to be aware and stop creating a demand. It might also get governments in some areas to create more bans on these products because they pose a known public health risk.

      Delete
  9. This is so terrible. I saw a show on Oasis tv where they had to breed white rhinos with black ones because there weren't enough white ones. :( Maybe something else needs to be put into place where these people can make more money protecting them.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The worst part is, that these poor rhinos don't even have healing properties. So its all for nothing.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Healing properties provided by grinding up animal horns... I didn't realize we were still stuck in the 7th century.

    ReplyDelete
  12. sally, i like how all your blogs are about large mammals. these are fun to read!

    ReplyDelete